I cannot with any accuracy report at all on the internal
guild events that you are mentioning there, nor do
I have any wish to, even if I had more knowledge and a
more informed opinion on those matters.

I do, however, have answers to some of the points you
brought up.

Why does being a citizen of Mhaldor suddenly constitute
that a person doesn't care for Nature anymore?--

Learn the History of the Red Fog. Learn the history of the
Sartaiwar. Learn the history of Mhaldor regarding breaking
its agreements with Oakstone.

You note an incident involving a young Sentinel who
became a traitor. You fail to note that he was held
responsible, cast out, enemied, and hunted. Quite a bit
of difference than making an agreement to enemy for using
a skill, then deciding once someone uses it to reneg
on the agreement.

You bring up the question of Evil and Neutrality.
History should show you one thing. Evil does not care
if you are neutral. Evil does not care if you do
not provoke it. Evil is Evil, and you are a victim so far
as it is concerned.

You note that it is "not the city that makes the
person". Quite true, so far as stating a pithy
observation that has little meaning. What is true, is that
a person is judged by who and what they pledge their
loyalties to. A city does not make a person. A person
choosing to support the goals of a city makes the
person.

Covenant Stormcrow

Penned by my hand on the 25th of Phaestian, in the year 350 AF.