Achaean News

Previous Article | Back to News Summary | Next Article
Public News Post #12291

Poor Thinking

Written by: Relos, Keeper of Keys
Date: Saturday, February 21st, 2004
Addressed to: Kirath Amaratha, Lichlord Botanist


This is, well, sorta on top of Nimby's post, on why you need to learn to
argue better.
You first post up a post showing how Lady Gaia enjoyed messing with
Sartanites, and congratulating the druid guild for it. This was Druid
post #3233. You then put up a post wherein she states that Druids have
freedom to choose what Divine to serve that they care to. This is post
#200. Meaning that by the later occuring post, #3233, she has quite
clearly changed her feelings, as per Nimby's post. You managed to not
only provide a poor argument, but also to directly contradict it
yourself. Congratulations, that is a feat of debating that I think will
never be willfully repeated.
And, just to add my own two cents, I somehow suspect Gaia would no
longer care for Sartan, even had she not have changed her feelings by
that latter post you pointed out, due to what happened later on to her
and her grove. Just a thought.
And, what the heck, might as well comment on this one as well, you make
mention of how Gaia messed with the Sartanites, as per post #3233 again,
and that that was why Sartan acted as he did. Well...again, doesn't that
kind of show something has changed between them by that point? If she
felt that way, I suspect something Sartan was doing didn't agree with
her.

With all due respect (*cough*)

- Relos

Penned by my hand on the 12th of Miraman, in the year 357 AF.


Previous Article | Back to News Summary | Next Article
Previous | Summary | Next
Public News Post #12291

Poor Thinking

Written by: Relos, Keeper of Keys
Date: Saturday, February 21st, 2004
Addressed to: Kirath Amaratha, Lichlord Botanist


This is, well, sorta on top of Nimby's post, on why you need to learn to
argue better.
You first post up a post showing how Lady Gaia enjoyed messing with
Sartanites, and congratulating the druid guild for it. This was Druid
post #3233. You then put up a post wherein she states that Druids have
freedom to choose what Divine to serve that they care to. This is post
#200. Meaning that by the later occuring post, #3233, she has quite
clearly changed her feelings, as per Nimby's post. You managed to not
only provide a poor argument, but also to directly contradict it
yourself. Congratulations, that is a feat of debating that I think will
never be willfully repeated.
And, just to add my own two cents, I somehow suspect Gaia would no
longer care for Sartan, even had she not have changed her feelings by
that latter post you pointed out, due to what happened later on to her
and her grove. Just a thought.
And, what the heck, might as well comment on this one as well, you make
mention of how Gaia messed with the Sartanites, as per post #3233 again,
and that that was why Sartan acted as he did. Well...again, doesn't that
kind of show something has changed between them by that point? If she
felt that way, I suspect something Sartan was doing didn't agree with
her.

With all due respect (*cough*)

- Relos

Penned by my hand on the 12th of Miraman, in the year 357 AF.


Previous | Summary | Next